RKG Logo

I’ll give you all I got to give if you say you love me too
I may not have a lot to give but what I got I’ll give to you
I don’t care too much for money, money can’t buy me love.
Paul McCartney

So Microsoft Live (via JellyFish) will soon be providing cash-back bonuses for consumers who use Microsoft search and then make a purchase. This is being reported as big news.

We’ve seen the spend-money-to-try-and-buy-love approach before. Many times. Usually at holiday season, when a portal or a search engine offered cash incentives to consumers to shop through them. The goal is to encourage new user adoption, and also (this is the cynical view) to bump traffic to impress Wall Street short-term. AOL did this regularly in the old days. Ditto Yahoo. Paypal. Google Checkout.

IMHO you can’t buy user loyalty. The savvy deal-focused shoppers will swoop in to use Microsoft during this deal, and then will swoop back to whatever search site they had been using when the deal ends. (Odds are, that would be Google.) Deal shoppers won’t stick. I don’t think you can buy share ongoing, even if you have as much cash as MSFT.

Who will be the real winner here?

Participating retailers.

Free money promotions are always a win for the stores when the free money comes from somewhere else.

Given this tough economy, it is good to see some online retailers getting something positive tossed their way.

Update: Ooops! Mistake in this post. Please see the following day’s post for clarification.

If you like this post, consider subscribing to our RSS feed. You can also have new posts sent to you via email.

Share this post (via email, Digg, Delicious, etc)

Possibly Similar Posts

Trackback

http://www.rimmkaufman.com/rkgblog/2008/05/22/live-search-cashback/trackback/

Blogs Citing This Post

  1. Pingback: Jellyfish Ramblings on May 23, 2008
  2. Pingback: Money Can’t Buy You Love, Redux on June 3, 2008

Your Comment

Email Updates

Categories

Recent Comments

  • George Michie: Thanks for your comments Ophir, you raise excellent points. Particularly as Geo-targeting competition in different areas moves...
  • SEO Services: Nice Post. Thanks for sharing this information with us.
  • Ophir Cohen: The Problem with Positions in SEM The whole concept of positions (1 vs 3 vs 15) has a lot of meaning when the goal of a campaign is...
  • George Michie: Thanks for your thoughts, Jason. I like your metaphor of the millions of query "channels". Indeed it may be that poor converting...
  • George Michie: Thanks Christian, I think they simply present those aggregate figures to highlight the difficulty: the data is incredibly sparse,...
  • Jason Anderson: Interesting Post. Seems likely that the same forces that produce a mix of regional and national advertising on television will...
  • Christian Little: Hey George, Regarding the university study, I read it over and I don't understand all the math, but I don't think it could be...
  • Elaine: Alan, Thanks for the Great post. As Eric mentioned, I'd love to see more on year-over-year analysis when you have it.
  • George Michie: Jonathan, thanks for your comment. I look forward to reading your book! Some Direct Marketers worry that the Big Brand Advertisers...
  • Adsense: Yes your comments are spot on. I hate the possibility of fraud and hope I never get accused by accident. If someone hates you enough they...
  • Jonathan Salem Baskin: I absolutely agree with your post, and am continually fascinated (and somewhat befuddled) by marketers' willingness to...
  • George Michie: Dan, I hear you! Ultimately Google will choose the ad that generates the most revenue. That will depend largely on customer intent...
  • dan: I find geo-targeting an alarming trend. The power of the internet is that you can get information, products and services from around the...
  • Alan Rimm-Kaufman: Oliver -- yes, there's always a tradeoff between sales and profits. Picking that tradeoff is the most important strategic...
  • George: Good point, Christian, Yep, far be it from me to criticize the marketing plans of huge, profitable, growing firms. Ultimately there is "hit...

Blog Stats

  • Posts: 757
  • Words: 335,687
  • Comments: 1,326

Administration

Close
  • Social Web
  • E-mail
Powered by ShareThis