RKG Logo 434-978-4300

I’ll give you all I got to give if you say you love me too
I may not have a lot to give but what I got I’ll give to you
I don’t care too much for money, money can’t buy me love.
Paul McCartney

So Microsoft Live (via JellyFish) will soon be providing cash-back bonuses for consumers who use Microsoft search and then make a purchase. This is being reported as big news.

We’ve seen the spend-money-to-try-and-buy-love approach before. Many times. Usually at holiday season, when a portal or a search engine offered cash incentives to consumers to shop through them. The goal is to encourage new user adoption, and also (this is the cynical view) to bump traffic to impress Wall Street short-term. AOL did this regularly in the old days. Ditto Yahoo. Paypal. Google Checkout.

IMHO you can’t buy user loyalty. The savvy deal-focused shoppers will swoop in to use Microsoft during this deal, and then will swoop back to whatever search site they had been using when the deal ends. (Odds are, that would be Google.) Deal shoppers won’t stick. I don’t think you can buy share ongoing, even if you have as much cash as MSFT.

Who will be the real winner here?

Participating retailers.

Free money promotions are always a win for the stores when the free money comes from somewhere else.

Given this tough economy, it is good to see some online retailers getting something positive tossed their way.

Update: Ooops! Mistake in this post. Please see the following day’s post for clarification.

If you like this post, consider subscribing to our RSS feed. You can also have new posts sent to you via email.


Related Posts

    • Money Can’t Buy You Love, Redux Microsoft to pay HP to make Live the default search engine in IE on new HP machines. Meanwhile, Ffox adoption continues to grow....
    • MSFT Search Woes Microsoft continues to lose search market share. And switching from serving Yahoo ads to their own AdCenter paid search system has decreased revenue per search....
    • Brand PPC: a Waste of Money?!? MSN and Atlas released a study suggesting that half of search budgets are wasted on brand search...whose campaigns are these guys looking at?!?...
    • Windows Live Beta Windows Live, the replacement for MSN Search, is in early beta at www.live.com. I'm going to switch to Live.com for the next week or so...

Your Comment

Tags

RKG Tags: , , , ,

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Trackback

http://www.rimmkaufman.com/rkgblog/2008/05/22/live-search-cashback/trackback/

Blogs Citing This Post

  1. Pingback: Jellyfish Ramblings on May 23, 2008
  2. Pingback: Money Can’t Buy You Love, Redux on June 3, 2008

Email Updates

Categories

Recent Comments

  • Lance: George - Thanks so much for the interview and the kind words. Jake - We have seen the gains from our tests hold up. But I am sensitive to...
  • Andrew@BloggingGuide: I liked what he said: our approach is to never be satisfied, and always seek incremental improvement. This is absolutely true...
  • Jake Minturn: Great interview! One thing I am curious about, and I’d love to get Lance’s take on this, is if these boosts in conversion...
  • Bob: Would your call center stop answering sales calls because they’ve reached their budgeted labor for the month? This is considered...
  • David: Great post George, nice to see technology story telling alive. Kept me gripped and v interesting.
  • Rex Dixon: @George - That is too bad to hear. I don’t believe we have any PPC test results on our site currently.
  • George Michie: Ken, You’re absolutely right if the CR difference between A and B is small (2 or 3%) the odds of A running the table...
  • Ken Truman: Shay - I definitely think the same logic applies to day of week analysis. George - That’s an extremely interesting way of...
  • George Michie: Hi Laurence, We think folks spend far too much time worrying about mythical penalties. The account QS is dominated by the QS on your...
  • Laurence: Hi George, Thank you for the enlightening post. You’ve sold me on how important the long tail is so over the past few weeks...
  • Billy Wolt: take-away: Make sure you are bidding on your brand, broad topic, and specific model keywords :)
  • George Michie: Thanks for the kind words Lance and Bryan. Andy, I feel your pain. I meant to include a section on why site exclusions didn’t...
  • Algernon: Yay for yahoo! Just in time for them to shut it all down and hand the keys to Microsoft. Sorry, as an advertiser who got hammered for...
  • Bryan: Excellent post, George! Now lets cross our fingers that the folks at Microsoft give us the ability to adjust bids by syndication partner...
  • Lance: Brilliant post, George. Here’s hoping things pan out this way and everyone wins.

Blog Stats

  • Posts: 947
  • Words: 450,092
  • Comments: 2,844

Administration