RKG Logo 434-978-4300

You know that old joke: the motivational speaker leads an audience in call-and-response, shouting, “Repeat after me, ‘I am an individual!’” and the crowd dutifully chants back as one, “I am an individual!”?

Word-of-mouth-marketing reminds me of that ironic joke. I have an image of WOM marketers huddled around the conference table, engineering “spontaneous” consumer-driven marketing and scripting “authentic” communication.

Seth Godin has it 100% right: you get buzz from being remarkable, not by trying to force buzz.

So I found it curious when Godin used BzzAgent to promote Small Is The New Big. When I asked Seth about this choice during Q&A at his Shop.org talk, his reponse was along the lines of “sometimes you have to pay.” Godin offers a different response recounting this exchange in his recent blog post (I think) praising pyramid schemes, where he (I think) compares paying for word-of-mouth to prostitution.

And TechCrunch reports on a set of PayPerPost-like startups based on paying folks to make product endorsements on their blogs, often without full disclosure.

I enjoyed a long lunch last week with Todd Tweedy of WordSpreadsQuickly and BoldMouth. Todd described how the Word Of Mouth Marketing Association (WOMA) is still in a bit of a spin due to Edelman’s involvement in the fake WalMartingAcrossAmerica blog.

I have two questions. One: can Word Of Mouth Marketing be done well and done honestly? And two: will marketers destroy the WOM concept by flooding the space with paid shills (just as spammers have nearly destroyed email)?

Todd Tweedy claims yes, WOM can be done honestly, and yes, WOM can survive a tragedy of the commons death. To learn more, I look forward to digging into Todd’s word-of-mouth research study this week.

If you like this post, consider subscribing to our RSS feed. You can also have new posts sent to you via email.


Related Posts

Comments

  1. Todd Tweedy, October 30, 2006:

    Hey Alan,

    Lunch was awesome. I’m glad we had a chance to connect and am looking forward to your insights and observations on our study.

    All the best,

    Todd Tweedy
    BoldMouth.com

Your Comment

Trackback

http://www.rimmkaufman.com/rkgblog/2006/10/30/word-of-mouth-marketing-study/trackback/

Email Updates

Categories

Recent Comments

  • Nancy Kast: I am writing about your billing and online services. I have been receiving calls saying my bill is not paid. My husband pays all our...
  • Marc Adelman: George, Thanks for sharing this data. From an online buzz perspective, Bing is making a big splash. Everyone is talking about it....
  • George Michie: Hi Dennis, I’m not a lawyer, so take anything I say on this with a grain of salt (and please don’t sue us if we’re...
  • survey online: unfortunatelly i have to say that Google tools are the easiest survey web
  • Dennis Yu: Alan, We’ve had several C&D’s sent to us for seemingly innocuous issues. One of our casual dining clients bid on a...
  • George Michie: Hi Vivek, Haven’t had time to put together a full update, but I did take a look at the numbers. No material gains in market...
  • Karridy: You should checkout ClickPath’s call to KW tracking.
  • Vivek: George, really enjoying reading about the analysis you guys do. Was wondering if you have an update on this given a couple more weeks have...
  • Vicki Swaim: Dear Mr.Ullman, I hope you can help me with my problem. I ordered a TV stand the end of April that was advertised as a close out item....
  • Luke: It’s a shame we live in such a litigious society. Why should we have to set up an association? Surely we can prevent senseless...
  • George Michie: Josh, we have had shots fired over our bow and our client’s in the past. Usually responsible companies are reasonable about...
  • Ryan: Ok, George, I’m sufficiently scared… Thanks… :-) Incidentally, are there any trademark resources (other than Google...
  • Josh: We have run into trademark issues for several clients, although it has so far been a matter of trying to make “fair use” of a...
  • Mike: THANK YOU! I love you man!! :)
  • Matthew: Francis, We’ve likewise seen the “A-List” phenomenon in the past. Perhaps with Bing.com, there won’t be anymore of...

Blog Stats

  • Posts: 871
  • Words: 392,916
  • Comments: 2,079

Administration